r/AskCulinary • u/AutoModerator • 10h ago
Weekly Discussion Weekly Ask Anything Thread for January 13, 2025
This is our weekly thread to ask all the stuff that doesn't fit the ordinary /r/askculinary rules.
Note that our two fundamental rules still apply: politeness remains mandatory, and we can't tell you whether something is safe or not - when it comes to food safety, we can only do best practices. Outside of that go wild with it - brand recommendations, recipe requests, brainstorming dinner ideas - it's all allowed.
r/AskCulinary • u/Loose-Chocolate7797 • 3h ago
Recipe Troubleshooting Why don’t my gummies come out stretchy?
I’ve been trying to experiment around with some different gummy recipes for a school fundraiser but nothing seems to come out as I intended. Here’s the following recipe I last used
4 Tbs Strawberry Juice 3 Tbs Sugar 2 Tbs Corn Syrup 1/2 Tbs Pectin 2 packets gelatin + 4 tbs water
This recipe was able to make gummies that had a nice exterior texture, but ultimately lacked in flavor and when I tried to pull it apart it just crumbled. Any advice for how I can edit this recipe for an overall more stretchy/ flavorful gummy?
r/AskCulinary • u/Possible-Source-2454 • 18h ago
Technique Question How do you make brown butter a more emulsified sauce for pasta?
I had some fresh pasta recently with brown butter and sage at a restaurant. However, It wasn’t like a pool of butter at the bottom like I make at home. It felt like it was really well incorporated sauce that clung to the pasta vs something broken. It kinda blew my mind— and every bite had the sage butter flavor. Maybe it was still just brown butter but curious thoughts?
r/AskCulinary • u/PetalbrookMayor • 20h ago
Equipment Question Pizza stone won’t stop smoking
Hello!
My parents recently gave me an old pizza stone they had. I’ve used it a couple times already but I’ve noticed that it smokes once it’s been heated up in the oven.
After researching, I found maybe it had some oils seeped into it and it was recommended that I basically just put it into the oven and let it all smoke out.
However, I’ve been doing that for over an hour on 475° and the pizza stone is still smoking. It’s not a heavy smoke but when I open the oven there’s definitely some smoke that comes out.
What does this mean? Should I just let it go even longer? Or is it done for and I should just buy another one?
Thank you!
r/AskCulinary • u/Historical_Sort1289 • 40m ago
You think I can make chicken Parm with a deep fryer?
To make a long story short I work in a kitchen at a Christian rehab/shelter. Cool for about 50 guys. I have cooking experience but just for me or a few people. I've been learning a lot as I go. Usually when I make chicken Parm I either get thin chicken breasts or cut them thin my shelf. Hammer them a bit and bread them with Italian bread crumbs and Parmesan cheese. Then since it's just for a few servings I add some oil to a pan and fry them. Anyways there is a deep fryer here. Wondering if that would work good. Also can I stack them up in there or will they stick together and rip the breading off? Better in small batches?
r/AskCulinary • u/werdnaegni • 18h ago
Technique Question Why doesn't adding a parmesan rind make a bunch of stringy/clumpy cheese due to the high heat, like often happens with Cacio e Pepe?
Title, basically. I don't quite understand how this doesn't cause issues with the cheese on the rind splitting. What's the difference here? Is it that the cheese gets leeched off a tiny bit at a time? Wouldn't that happen with any cheese? I'm confused. Thanks!
r/AskCulinary • u/CleanWolverine7472 • 6h ago
Need advice on temperature while making beef stock
Hey everyone, Yesterday was my first serious attempt to make a quality beef stock. I had roasted the bones (mostly cross-section marrow and some shank bones, some meat included) beforehand and had also roasted the vegetables. Added some port for acidity. Had enough water in to cover everything. Stock was on for a total time of about 11 hours, but vegetables went in towards the end at the 9 hour mark, and the aromatics at the 10 hour mark. Here's the thing: The stock didn't gel as 'shown' in most YouTube videos and I'm trying to determine why that is. Maybe I wasn't cooking the stock hot enough? I even had a thermometer in the stockpan to monitor things and my temp hovered between 82 (180°F) and 95°C (200°F). What gets me is that there mostly advised to use the lowest possible setting on your stove, but to maintain a simmer. I have induction so the lowest setting goes pretty low, but should I try to get more in the direction of that slow simmer for the collagen extraction that helps with gelling? I think I'm missing some theory here that would help with getting better results. I suspect I should have had a couple knuckle bones in there l but for a 12 hour extraction I thought that shouldn't be a problem. Any advice from the pros here would be appreciated! Thank you!
r/AskCulinary • u/mszegedy • 19h ago
I usually pull my own noodles. (Biangbiang and oil noodles.) But when I cook for my mother, I have to use gluten-free flour. (A starch blend, mainly tapioca.) Am I doomed? Can I still pull noodles?
When I try to make dough out of gluten-free flour, it is not solid or stretchy. It's just shear-thickening. I can change the viscosity by changing the water content, but I can't make it permanently retain its shape the way gluten dough does. (I thought egg might help, but as of yet it has not helped.) Am I doing something wrong? Is there a way for me to create dough that I can pull into noodles?
(More information on the nature of my mother's objection to gluten: she does not have coeliac; she has a gluten allergy. This allergy was diagnosed by a quack, so I'm not sure she has even that, but I'm not going to lie to her about the ingredients of her food, and I'm not going to serve food with ingredients she doesn't want.)
r/AskCulinary • u/irondumbell • 1d ago
Does it matter what side of aluminum foil to use?
There is a glossy and non glossy side and I've read that which side you use matters. For example if you make a foil boat to bake things in, either the glossy or non glossy faces the inside, i forget which. But does it really matter which side to use?
r/AskCulinary • u/ohsweetdeezus • 12h ago
Technique Question What’s wrong with my potatoes?
Whenever I roast a chicken in a cast iron, I chop up some wedge potatoes and stick them around the chicken, hoping for some delicious chicken drippings soaked goodness.
When the chicken is done, my potatoes have an unpleasant texture. They seem to be all the way cooked through but the outside is weirdly chewy but the potatoes also fall apart.
Some details: I’ve had similar reactions trying with gold and russet potatoes. Potatoes are tossed in avocado oil and salt. The chicken is dry brined with a salt/baking powder mix the night before and rubbed with butter before the oven. Cast iron is heated in 400 degree oven, chicken is plopped in to jumpstart thighs, I surround the chicken with the potatoes Bake one hour-ish to 155f
r/AskCulinary • u/Anxious-Rent-2414 • 7h ago
New Korean Oven Help
Hi guys. I'm not sure if this is the right place to post this so if it's not, please let me know where to ask.
So before I came to Korea, I took an interest in baking everything. I wanted to make everything from scratch such as bread and cakes and more. I did get stationed overseas and I now have this new oven. It's a conventional oven and im super confused.
I tried to make bread and followed the temperature and everything but the inside was still a bit raw and the outside was golden. It baked really fast. It also was really hard... I tried again and same problem. I wanted to make banana bread but I don't know if I should anymore. I wanted to make bread today to make pasta but I don't want it to burn or anything.
I've never used an oven that uses fans. It doesn't let me manage how strong I want the air in the oven while it's baking. Maybe im missing sometjing obvious, but im getting disheartened because I just started to bake and now I have this oven that rotates like a microwave and blows air. I was wondering if anyone of you guys know what I can do because I found something I enjoyed and I don't want to give it up for the next 3 years...
Its not letting me add any attachments but it's a LG lightwave DIOS. It has an oven button, grill button on the very right and 3 other buttons in Korean, a twist know in the middle, a choose button, 2 other korean buttons that i don't know what it means, and clear button, and a start button. I don't know how you guys can answer without the photos and a terrible description, but i appreciate any advice. ♡
r/AskCulinary • u/doseNeedlePoint • 17h ago
Ingredient Question Lentils in Cabbage rolls
If I'm subbing lentils for rice do I need to pre boil the lentils? I know they take way little time versus most other beans.
r/AskCulinary • u/its_al_dente • 14h ago
Ingredient Question Coconut milk smelling and tasting like plastic or maybe soap?
Curry was tasting and smelling good. Cracked a can of coconut milk to put in. I noticed a plastic smell. I proceeded anyway and put it in. A bit of cooking later I tasted the curry and it tasted like plastic or soap and was quite bitter on the mid-back pallet. What the hell is going on?! Any knowledge is appreciated.
r/AskCulinary • u/Funny-Big1440 • 9h ago
Brown butter cookies
What is the difference/affects of freezing vs chilling cookie dough? I am using a brown butter chocolate chip cookie recipe if that matters.
r/AskCulinary • u/Fabulous_Theme8353 • 10h ago
Recipe Troubleshooting Cream puff failure
I’m in a culinary class and we’re making cream Puffs tommorow so I figured I could get some Practice in tonight. I got all my ingredients prepped and did the recipe almost exactly to a T. The recipe called for one cup water, one whole stick of butter, 1/2 tsp salt, and one cup of flour. I figured it wouldn’t be a big deal to add in some sugar for a sweater dough and put in a full tablespoon. The recipe we got told us to melt our butter in boiling water so I put my butter (I used two half sticks of land o lakes butter) in the boiling water and let them melt completely. Shortly after I added in my sugar, salt, and flour all at once and started stirring, soon after though my dough just looked like applesauce and had the same consistency. I stirred for over ten minutes on different heats and nothing changed. I ended up adding more flour which sort of helped but in the end my dough still looked like applesauce. I kept chugging on and added my eggs but still afterward, though more stiff, it still looked like applesauce. I cooked the dough for the length and temp required and this was the final product. What did I do wrong? Edit: I forgot to attach the photo before posting, if needed I can hopefully get the photo to anyone that needs it.
r/AskCulinary • u/Ok-Strike1455 • 11h ago
My chicken won’t freeze!
Ok on Jan 6 I bought a package of chicken breasts at Walmart. Took it home, sliced each piece in half and put 2 halves in its own ziploc bag before going into the freezer. On January 7, I noticed that one of the ziplocs hadn't frozen up yet. So I thought maybe there was something wrong with the fridge/freezer but then I see that everything else is still frozen and the other ziplocs of chicken froze up. Next thought was maybe it was because of where that ziploc landed in the freezer, maybe it was somehow blocked by something that prevented it from freezing (I really was grasping at straws) Well anyway here it is Jan 12 and it's still not frozen!! everything in my freezer is frozen except this ziploc of chicken breast. People of Reddit: Any ideas?
r/AskCulinary • u/holisticblue • 1d ago
Technique Question Why do we add liquid to pot roasts and other slow cooked meats?
Hi guys :) I have been cooking at home for quite a while now, but I am very new to doing low and slow cooked meats. My question is, what's the point of adding liquid, and how do you actually do it correctly? To me it seems like leaving meat in hot liquid for hours would cause it to be tough and gummy, but clearly that's wrong because pot roast is a classic and comes out amazing when done right
r/AskCulinary • u/feardedbellows • 1d ago
Tom Kha Gai recipe - if using only thighs instead of an entire cut up chicken, will this yield adequate results?
Here is the recipe I am referring to: https://shesimmers.com/2013/03/tom-kha-gai-the-rustic-way.html
As mentioned in the title, in this version the author uses a whole cut up chicken and simmers it for 40 minutes is a low volume of water (to get a sort of quick concentrated broth). If I did the same thing but with skin on bone in thighs, would my end result suffer?
Thanks in advance
r/AskCulinary • u/Apart_Value9613 • 1d ago
Technique Question [Custard?] Recipe calls for mixing egg yolks, milk, sugar, then boiling it for four minutes. Why don’t the egg yolks become scrambled?
The closest term I could find was custard. When you boil egg yolks they become solid and powdery. But why don’t they split when boiled over the stovetop? (The recipe is an Ottoman dessert called “Keşkül” if anyone is wondering)
r/AskCulinary • u/mindar76 • 1d ago
Duck wellington and the mushroom replacement
Look, I know that sounds like a weird animated kid's movie, but I swear it's relevant.
I absolutely love duck, and I've been kicking around an idea of making a duck wellington. I have both the duck breasts and some duck breast prosciutto. My problem is my wife is allergic to mushrooms, so I'm trying to find an alternative. I'm thinking diced chestnuts but I'm not sure it'll give the right earthyness of mushrooms. I saw a recipe where the writer uses soy sauce and congnac while cooking down the chestnuts. I'm iffy on that combination. Regardless, since I'm dealing with duck I'll be likewise substituting the shallots in the duxelle with melted leeks, since it's a very similar flavor profile, but that duck and leek are just such a good combination.
A friend had recommended tempeh into the faux duxelle, but I've never used it before so I'm unfamiliar with the flavor, texture or haven't of the ingredient.
If anyone has suggestions, I'm ducky to hear them!
r/AskCulinary • u/Dynamometamorphe • 22h ago
Equipment Question Scratched Stainless Pan [any tips]
Hi !
So I inherited my grandma’s stainless steel pan, but years of using a metal sponge (wrong way of cleaning a stainless steel pan, I know...) left it super scratched.
As I'm using this stainless pan, the food is constantly sticking to my pan. Even if it tried the water droplet test, different oils and gentler cleaning method (even if it's already super scratched...)
Could deep scratches be why food sticks more ? Can I polish a heavily scratched stainless pan to improve it? (in my opinion it's not recommended as I haven't found people doing that).
- Has anyone restored a similar pan?
- What techniques or products worked for you?
- Are there risks or pitfalls with polishing stainless steel?
Thanks in advance!
r/AskCulinary • u/BigAHol • 22h ago
Meal prepping/freezing in deli containers at home
Home cook here!
For dietary reasons and to reduce my time in the kitchen, I want to start scaling up my meal prep and storing cooked meals for 1-2 months in the freezer that could be easily reheated. I'm thinking these would mostly be simple grain+protein+veg meals or soups. Ideally I'm prepping things that could be dumped in a bowl, microwaved, and still be tasty and nutritious.
I already have a ton of plastic deli containers which I would love to use for this, but I'm afraid of how cooked food will fare only in a deli container in the freezer. I figure most soups and liquid immersed foods will do fine, but are there ways to still use these containers and keep dry-ish food like rice and cooked chicken/fish fresh in the freezer? Would it be enough for me to just fill the containers to the top to reduce the amount of space for air inside? Or should I abandon all of this and invest in a vacuum sealer?
Thanks!
r/AskCulinary • u/Zepulchure • 1d ago
Technique Question Veggie "meatballs" help
I want to make meatballs in curry sauce for my partner, she is vegetarian however, and the only way I know how to make the dish, is with the boiled water from making the meatballs (more taste)
However, having never cooked with veggie replacements (nor Cooked much in general) i wondered if the, pre-made veggie-mince?? Or whatever you would call it,,, can be boiled like normal minced meat?
Mix egg, flour, chopped onion, then form them to balls with a spoon and directly into the water?
Sorry for the basic question, never learned how to cook, so my only knowledge is what I'm used to make for myself, much of that is probably wrong in any case 😅
r/AskCulinary • u/NotGeorge2019 • 1d ago
Central / wok ring not staying on
We have a new gas hob. All 4 outer rings are fine, central one will light but as soon as we let go of the knob the flame goes out, any ideas?
It is different to all other rings, instead of small holes it has 2 large ones and some adapter pieces
r/AskCulinary • u/Apprehensive_Fish_58 • 1d ago
How to unthick Pistachio butter | Dubai Chocolate
I recently bought 100% pistachio butter and mixed it with melted white chocolate and butter. After refrigerating the mixture, I left it at room temperature for three hours, but it didn't return to a liquid consistency. I tried reheating it using a double boiler, but it remained thick.
The reason I prepared the mixture earlier was that I had work and needed to finish it later. My goal is to combine it with kunafa to make Dubai chocolate.
Do you have any tips for ensuring the mixture becomes creamy and smooth when I make the Dubai chocolate?
r/AskCulinary • u/Clock_Wise_ • 1d ago
Ingredient Question Should saffron be bloomed using hot water or ice cubes?
I've been looking at instructions on the proper preparation of saffron and I've found two opposite methods:
Some recipes call for blooming with hot water.
Some others encourage sprinkling the saffron on ice cubes and letting them infuse while melting.
Which of these do you guys think is more effective for achieving satisfactory results?