r/privacy 7d ago

Apple opts everyone into having their Photos analyzed by AI news

https://www.theregister.com/2025/01/03/apple_enhanced_visual_search/
4.4k Upvotes

View all comments

Show parent comments

22

u/Technoist 7d ago

Thanks! Turned it off. No idea why anyone would want/need to have this.

9

u/I_Want_To_Grow_420 7d ago

To easily search photos. I understand the privacy risks but can see the positives as well. My grandmother is a wreath maker. She has thousand of photos of her wreaths and others for ideas. She can search "black orange wreath with spiders" and it will find all of the wreaths that are black and orange and feature spiders.

6

u/Technoist 7d ago

Hmm, I have been able to search for detailed objects by text in my photos for years. As I understand it, this thing is about recognizing places (buildings etc) and not persons, pets, objects.

2

u/I_Want_To_Grow_420 7d ago

Yeah, same thing, just updated. Now if it sees a mountain, it can guess if it's Mt. Kilimanjaro or a different mountain.

As you said, it's been around for years, so it's strange that people are just now getting upset about it. Any time is better than never though.

2

u/Technoist 7d ago edited 7d ago

Isn't this new though? First of all, we have not been able to disable it before (it wasn't a switch in the settings - that is definitely new), also I am sure now that this is turned off Photos will still be able to ID my cat or a red jacket or a blue butterfly just fine, as it always did. This is surely just for landmarks. I already have location data enabled so I already know I was at Kilimanjaro, I don't need this crap and I certainly don't need to feed their database with my image metadata.

Nothing in the texts I have found describes this other than only a new database for landmarks.

Edit: As u/qdtk writes, all previous object identification was done locally.

6

u/qdtk 7d ago

Yes this is new. It’s actually sending (encrypted?) data off your device for analysis. The old method is entirely on your device.

2

u/Technoist 7d ago

Thanks for verifying.