r/heat • u/TerryG111 • 1d ago

Should Herro become an All Star? Discussion

I would say Tyler has earned it. Even though I am not a Heat fan respectfully, I can appreciate talent when I see it and Herro this season has been healthy. He has been ballin. He is putting up All Star numbers right now in Miami. More than earned it in my book.

66 Upvotes

88% Upvoted

View all comments

7

u/eeevileggg 1d ago

As much as I think he’s playing at an all star level, the also has to beat other guards for the spot: Mitchell, Brunson, Lillard, Maxey, Lamello, Jaylen Brown.

7

u/chitownbulls92 1d ago

Both Maxey and Lamelo have been quite injured compared to Herro and both the Sixers and hornets have really bad records.

8

u/DalliLlama 1d ago

And he should be ahead of every single one of them aside from Dame, Melo and maybe Jaylen. Record would favor Donovan and Jaylen, but he’s arguable been top 3 of that list and for sure top 4.

0

u/Dr-Underwood 1d ago

Brunson???

1

u/DalliLlama 1d ago

I’d take Herro this year for the nod. Jalen may have higher highs still, but he’s been more inconsistent this year. Basically average same stats all around, Nalen better passer, Herro better rebounder, bout same points. But Herro is doing it with way less help and night in and night out. Herros lowest game is 14 points, Jalen already has 5 such games. Jalen just has a few higher games that balance it out in the long run.

I wouldn’t throw a fit about Jalen getting it over Herro, but I think Herro has been the better player thus far.

-1

u/Dr-Underwood 1d ago

This is one of the most delusional takes I've ever read lol. Brunson will be 1st or 2nd team All-NBA, Herro isn't close to that..

And by your logic, Cade has better numbers with less help.. or does that only apply for Herro?

0

u/DalliLlama 1d ago edited 1d ago

No Brunson wont with the way he’s playing at the moment and others are, especially with it being positionless… and I did forget about Cade. He’s very deserving of a spot. I’d take him over Herro too.

0

u/Dr-Underwood 17h ago

24/3/7 on 48/42/81 splits for a top-5 team... he is absolutely making All-NBA unless he gets hurt. I don't think you've watched many Knicks games

1

u/DalliLlama 17h ago

Sounds like Herro is all nba then, let alone all star.

0

u/Dr-Underwood 17h ago

LOL less points, less assists, worse efficiency, worse team... sure man. Real close

1

u/DalliLlama 17h ago

Same pts, less assists, more rebounds, worse team, exactly, doing more with less. If only Herro had someone like Kat, Mikal, Hart on the team.

→ More replies

4

u/Both_Funny4896 1d ago

add Trae, Garland and Cade to that list. The east guard class is pretty deep this year.

1

u/garret126 1d ago

Jaylen is a forward and made an All NBA as a forward. Him making it as a guard would be a sham

1

u/TheShadowOverBayside Tyler Thee Herro 1d ago

He's on the Allstar ballot as frontcourt so that's all there is to it