Seriously, what is wrong with Carla? [discussion]

[u/Mandalorian_Ronin]

Currently on the Infinity Clock arc of my rewatch and I gotta ask, why is Carla so quiet about everything?

Nothing good has come from her keeping her mouth shut. More than once, Carla gets some kind of premonition and every time someone asks what's wrong, she's all "Nothing, its ok."

You'd think that after the whole event in Edolas, she's know better than to dismiss her visions. Even if she has no clear cut explanation, she should be smart enough to at least let everyone know she's seeing things.

[u/LovelyLadyLucky]

I agree with everything everyone said i mentioned this in another discussion about GMG quite a while ago but to recap,

She has a hard believing her visions because she mistook her previous visions has a message from Edolas that ended up being completely wrong.

She's also quite young herself. I know exceeds view time differently but her and happy at that point in the story were only hatched 6 years prior. She's still learning not just magic, but also herself. She comes off arrogant and a bit pompous and I imagine that bothers her when she does end up being wrong so she doesn't say anything yet because she doesn't know how to handle not knowing everything when she comes off as quite a know-it-all.