Seriously, what is wrong with Carla? [discussion]

[u/Mandalorian_Ronin]

Currently on the Infinity Clock arc of my rewatch and I gotta ask, why is Carla so quiet about everything?

Nothing good has come from her keeping her mouth shut. More than once, Carla gets some kind of premonition and every time someone asks what's wrong, she's all "Nothing, its ok."

You'd think that after the whole event in Edolas, she's know better than to dismiss her visions. Even if she has no clear cut explanation, she should be smart enough to at least let everyone know she's seeing things.

[u/Ryuuji_Gremory]

You'd think that after the whole event in Edolas, she's know better than to dismiss her visions. 

You mean the time she relied on her visions to lead her friends into a trap, making her seem like a traitor and nearly get them all killed? If anything that would stop her from ever relying on it again.

I don't remember that specific arc as I have seen/read less often than the rest of the series (due to it not being in the manga) but in the material adapted from the manga her visions are often fragmented and abstract not giving her a clear picture what is happening just bits and pieces that could mean a thousand things. And as already mentioned, the last time she trusted those fragmented bits and pieces she nearly got the whole guild killed.