r/beyonce 12h ago

Rolling Stone names Beyoncé’s ‘Lemonade’ as the Greatest Album of the 21st Century. News

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-lists/best-albums-21st-century-1235177256/radiohead-kid-a-6-1235188695/

Citation:

Since the release of her self-titled fifth album in 2013, each Beyoncé volume has leveled up in some way — yet Lemonade bests them all in storytelling, revelation, and cultural resonance. In all she’s accomplished, she has yet to meet the world as vulnerably as she does here, laying bare the trauma of her very famous husband’s infidelity to their marriage and the empire they built upon it. Still, the shock and intrigue from that ends up trailing far behind the defining ethos Beyoncé constructs from her despair.

It starts with intricate songs that span time and genre, from the sugary, Soulja Boy-sampling reggae of “Hold Up” to the hard rock “Don’t Hurt Yourself” with Jack White to the country yarn “Daddy Lessons.” From there, Lemonade is foundational to the wide arc of studied genius we’ve come to expect from Beyoncé in subsequent years: For instance, the disrespect she and the Chicks faced performing “Daddy Lessons” at the 2016 Country Music Awards informed her hard pivot South eight years later on Cowboy Carter. Perhaps Lemonade incentivized the utter excellence of every work that followed because of its stunning losses at the 2017 Grammys — her third time losing Album of the Year, with another loss to come. For many, that night crystalized that being the best as a Black woman might never be enough. Yet, she continued to be just that.

Lemonade has always been is more than just an album. It’s a music film as layered, gorgeous, and haunting as a canonical drama, a matrix of generational heartbreak, a celebration of legacy, and a hand-drawn map to the intersections of many Black women’s interpersonal and political lives. That last aspect was especially palpable when “Freedom” became Kamala Harris’ 2024 presidential campaign theme. In 2016, the defiance and Black radical aesthetic of Lemonade’s hit single “Formation” was so bold that some police unions spitefully called for a boycott of Beyoncé — Lemonade soundtracked a shifting world, and rocked it too. While valid concerns exist as to whether she actually lives out the values of the social iconography she’s channeled or fundamentally contradicts them, the merits of Beyoncé’s artistry are undeniable. Put simply, Lemonade solidified her status among the best musicians of all time.

772 Upvotes

View all comments

142

u/Euphoric_Sea_2404 9h ago edited 9h ago

Btw, she’s #1 🏆on the list 🍋!

🚨Self-titled is #16

🚨Renaissance is #37

🚨Cowboy Carter is #126

40

u/Madam_Nicole 9h ago

Idk, self titled above Renaissance…. I’m just a whore for Renaissance so what do I know

And the CC disrespect….

20

u/texasjkids 8h ago

I can understand how self titled made it higher because it was more of a MOMENT, but damn Renaissance is my favorite Beyoncé album. Absolute masterpiece to me.

11

u/anonmarmot17 8h ago

I mean self titled changed the whole music charts, which in itself is a ridiculous feat