Yeah, ahh, when he was literally up to committing a mutiny remember? And when the essence of Holdo's plan had also been revealed to him. Like did you forget that, or just didn't think your comment through?
He specifically held back the information from her beforehand because he knew that Holdo would not see it his way. In turn, Holdo knew Poe would react as he did to her plan and in so doing endanger it.
Holdo proved him right. The entire remnant of the Resistance fleet was lost under her command. Every. Single. Ship. The remaining Resistance soldiers were then marooned on Krait, with no assistance coming for them, under the presumption the First Order wouldn't look out of a window. Despite the fact that the command bridge of every single star destroyer for at least 30 years has giant panaramic windows. Guys like Vader and Kylo Ren tend to look out of exactly those windows frequently and menacingly. Guys who are literally in command and can adjust plans based on things they can see with their eye balls.
The only reason anyone survived Holdo's objectively stupid and suicidal plan at all, was because Rey (someone Holdo has literally never met, much less knows is all-powerful-Jedi) miraculously showed up in the Falcon at the last second, and inexplicably lifted the side of a mountain off. Being that there was no way Holdo could've possibly accounted for that potentiality, Holdo's plan was objectively bad, and Poe was dead right about her "plan". Everyone who mutinied alongside Poe against Holdo, because they were sure she was going to get them all killed? They were 100% correct. She got them all killed.
13
u/SolomonOf47704 Mar 09 '21
He
LITERALLY
did.