r/geography Geography Enthusiast 26d ago

Why aren't there any large cities in this area? Discussion

Post image
11.0k Upvotes

View all comments

Show parent comments

212

u/idkrandomusername1 26d ago

Omaha freaked me out because there wasn’t anyone in the downtown area when I was there. It was a Saturday afternoon and it became foggy. Felt like I was in silent hill walking around

50

u/DepRatAnimal 26d ago

When did you live there? Omaha has had a bigger bounce-back for their downtown from COVID than almost any Midwest city. https://nebraskapublicmedia.org/en/news/news-articles/downtown-omaha-primed-for-growth-recovering-quicker-than-peers/

50

u/idkrandomusername1 26d ago

This was only for a day in 2015, it was cheaper to fly out of there than another nearby city. When I heard about the population size I was anticipating it to be more bustling but didn’t realize how spread out the population is. Also nothing was open except for a jimmy johns? Uncanny vibes, would go back

16

u/DepRatAnimal 26d ago

Must’ve been a bad day! I lived right outside of downtown from 2012-2015 and downtown always had a lot going on, especially the Old Market area. Omaha also has a lot less suburbanization and sprawl than comparable cities.

One thing that may have thrown you off, though, is that the city of Omaha takes up a large percentage of the metro area population compared to comparable metro areas. This is due to annexation policy that has allowed the city to annex more suburbs than cities in other states. So if you look at city sizes, Omaha appears larger than it does if you look at metropolitan statistical area sizes.

5

u/DirtyYogurt 26d ago

I lived there 2016 to be 2019 and downtown was plenty busy?

Like there's the commercial side of town and that was kind of dead outside of business hours, but the area in/around the old market was always busy in my experience.

2

u/DariusRuckerPark 26d ago

I was in Omaha for only one day, a Fall Sunday in 2017, and I had the same experience. We drove around downtown for 30 minutes until we found a restaurant that was open for lunch. The city was completely desolate. I figured it was because it was a Sunday afternoon.

2

u/jkgaspar4994 22d ago

I lived in Lincoln 2012-2016 and thought Omaha downtown was kind of quiet outside of the Old Market area.

I visited downtown again this year for the first time since like 2016 and I was impressed by how lively it was!

2

u/luckyapples11 26d ago

Downtown area used to be kinda shit. Not “no one ever goes there” bad, old market has always been busy. But pretty much any other part wasn’t very popular. Tons of new expansion and improvements, plus population increasing, it’s busy every single day, year round, even with a ton of snow lol

1

u/Bandandforgotten 26d ago

Bro, this is how Aberdeen, Washington, felt.

That place is LIMINAL. Every time I've visited, which granted was about 5 years ago now, and about 2 years in between for the visits before, it's felt like an almost abandoned town. Nobody walking their dogs, using sidewalks or anything. Only about one car would drive through the area each hour. My great grandmother used to live out there, and her house felt like it was as haunted as the town, complete with very old and aged decor.

The only place that I can remember was open, was a Denny's where all the people in the corner stared at us while we had a family breakfast with my uncle's family and my extended older family. They weren't even being discrete about it, I just remember them looking at us on either disgust or pure judgement, with a couple of them not looking away at all. It was super unsettling.

I kinda want to visit again and see if I can't get proof of this, because I'm half convinced it's a town full of people who seem human, but are actually a government experiment to see if we can identify them from real people.

0

u/LogisticalNightmare 26d ago

Downtown is for tourists tbh. I avoided it when I lived there unless I was trying to entertain someone from out of town.

2

u/cherrybombbb 26d ago

Tourists go to Omaha?

1

u/LogisticalNightmare 26d ago

For the College World Series, the Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting, and families drive from surrounding states for the Zoo. I know it sounds like BS if you’ve never experienced it.

1

u/cherrybombbb 26d ago

Oh I’ve been there— my aunt and uncle live in Omaha. I was just shocked other people go there without an explicit reason. Didn’t know about the college World Series.

1

u/psyspoop 26d ago

The CWS basically make downtown pretty inaccessible to the locals for a good chunk of June. Couples in the area often avoid having their weddings during that time because it's difficult for traveling family members to find lodging.

0

u/Naughtynuzzler 26d ago edited 26d ago

You were there on Sunday, not Saturday. I was born and raised in Omaha, and everything closes early (or doesnt open at all) on Sunday downtown except fast food places.

2

u/Sooooooooooooomebody 26d ago

Thank you for the link to Nebraska local media, because I ended up going down a rabbit hole about the time the Nebraska government approved a law that allowed parents to abandon their children and one guy abandoned all 9 of his kids at different places all over Omaha

1

u/DepRatAnimal 26d ago

LMAO

3

u/Sooooooooooooomebody 26d ago

It was a completely insane law. Apparently it was intended so that people with newborn babies could give them up at firehouses, hospitals, etc. without being punished. But they forgot to put an age limit in, so people came from all over the country to abandon their teenage kids in Nebraska for almost 2 straight years

2

u/psyspoop 26d ago

Lol I remember this from when I was a kid. My mom would threaten to leave us at a fire station if we were being bad.

-16

u/nancythethot 26d ago

"midwest"

13

u/slightly_comfortable 26d ago

Omaha is indisputably Midwest

3

u/Trix_Are_4_90Kids 26d ago

Omaha freaking sucks.

2

u/beachedwhitemale 26d ago

Wichita is also like this, but smaller. No one around downtown during the daytime but then it turns on at night. It's weird. 

2

u/7thGrandDad 26d ago

I’ve always lived in the nyc vicinity so maybe this is why, but lots of cities seem to be like this which freaks me out. Same thing happened to me in Providence of all places — totally dead on an autumn Saturday

2

u/Asscanor001 26d ago

Same thing happened to me but it was Detroit

2

u/alksreddit 26d ago

Feels just like when I visited Raleigh almost 15 years ago too. Completely desolate on a Sunday afternoon, almost eerie.

2

u/another-reddit-noob 26d ago

this is how i felt about des moines

2

u/goodoldjefe 26d ago

I had the same experience. Where are the people?

1

u/True_Distribution685 26d ago

This is how I felt as a New Yorker driving from my borough to Manhattan for the first time during COVID. It’s still the only time I’ve ever seen the city empty. So unnerving

1

u/Brief_Seat9721 26d ago

Probably during a huskers game lol

1

u/AirierWitch1066 26d ago

Was gonna say this. If it was a fall Saturday then most of the state migrates to Lincoln

1

u/ShawnyMcKnight 26d ago

I work in downtown Omaha and it’s crazy how not busy downtown is during the work day. Apparently a lot of places suffered with covid. Being from Lincoln downtown is right next to the college, so downtown is often busy.

1

u/nmessina17 26d ago

I’ve only been there once and had the same experience. I was there for work and we walked from our hotel to a bar about 15 minutes away. It was a perfect pink sunset in August and we did not see a single person outside. Big difference from the northeast. It wasn’t a sketchy area I think everyone just drives everywhere even it it’s nice out.

1

u/Wildest83 26d ago

That's what happens then the huskers play. I used to live there and loved to go shopping on Saturdays.

1

u/psyspoop 26d ago

Depends on the day/time. Even these days downtown can be eerily quiet at certain times of the week, but it also gets crazy busy at times (especially Friday and Saturday evenings)