r/clevercomebacks • u/Bad-Umpire10 • 19h ago
"Every human being deserves shelter and a meal"
42
u/Chelular07 17h ago
I love how they like to say don’t feed the bears as an analogy to don’t help the poor.
When bears have habitat, they have access to resources to keep them alive. They have access to food and shelter and water that they can utilize to keep themselves alive.
Is there a single place in the world that a human can do that without money? Is there a single place in America or other capitalistic countries that a human could build themselves a shelter and not have to worry about ANY legal repercussions? Is there a single water source in capitalist societies that is safe and legal for humans to utilize without paying their municipalities?
14
5
u/StanleyQPrick 16h ago
North Sentinel Island! But you can’t move there. Well, you can, but it will be the last thing you do.
-1
u/ShardsOfSalt 15h ago
Well water is often safe to use and free. But for your larger point no.
5
u/Chelular07 14h ago
Yeah, but you can only put a well on land that you own with a permit in most cases. So it still costs money.
55
u/Fearless_Spring5611 19h ago
Red probably believes in the "immigrants eats pets" story and thinks Blue is on their side.
6
u/DressMajestic9037 16h ago
Right, you can’t use sarcasm like this anymore because idiots can’t differentiate between sarcasm and a regular statement
9
u/Old-Tiger-4971 17h ago
Add in that every Black child deserves an education just as good as what White children get in public schools.
1
u/Round_Reception_1534 14h ago
yes, but only in "their" schools again! they propably still cherish "separate, but equal" policy
3
u/ProfessionalOwn9435 18h ago
Red pill dilema: Would you give a salmon carcas to homeless or the bear?
1
u/StanleyQPrick 16h ago
Is it desiccated?
1
u/ProfessionalOwn9435 16h ago
Sure. You can even cook it if the beer is cute.
1
u/StanleyQPrick 16h ago
I don’t know how anyone would cook that. Be like cooking a potato chip. Bear (or beer) can have it. Not human food.
2
1
u/Bennjoon 16h ago
Yeah I mean we let murderers on death row starve out in the rain right? Because that’s normal right? /s
Imagine arguing with this take jfc
1
u/AllTheWorldIsAPuzzle 15h ago
I propose Twitter add an "AI Hypocrisy" flag system. When someone tweets a comment about humans not deserving food, shelter, or basic human dignity; AI should scan their past tweets, liked content, etc. for anything where they were condemning abortion or praising Jesus or other hypocritical activity where they portrayed themselves as a "good Christian" or "pro-life" and then add that context to their tweet. I might actually get a Twitter account at that point just to watch AI showcase people's hypocrisy for all to see.
1
u/Maximum-Elk8869 15h ago
I have found without fail that the most devout, in your face Christians are always the most un-Christ like in their actions and deeds. They will throw Jesus in your face at every turn but ask them to tell you about the Sermon on the Mount and the Beatitudes and they go silent.
1
1
u/ComprehensiveSun3295 12h ago
I'll never understand why there is such a burning hatred for poor people. It really is a shame that you only deserve to live if you have money.
1
u/Brosenheim 10h ago
You don't feed bears beva
Cause they'll associate people with food, which creates problems. I'm pretty sure that "cause tbey'll get dependent" thing was just a lie they told boomers to appeal to their "got mine, fuck you" attitude
1
u/Enough-Parking164 9h ago
“Useless Eaters” is the term the uberwealthy are taught growing up. “Useless” meaning significant profits can not be made off of them for the trust funds and portfolios,therefore-NO RIGHT TO EXIST.
•
-32
u/burndmymouth 17h ago
Sorry, but no one "deserves" anything. There ain't no such thing as a free lunch.
24
u/Joelle9879 17h ago
Um yes. People absolutely "deserve" things. Human rights are a thing
-7
u/burndmymouth 15h ago
Human rights are not tangible goods though. Foundational Human Rights Principles Human dignity. Universality and interdependence of rights. Equality and non-discrimination. Meaningful participation. Accountability and the right to an effective remedy.
4
u/tw_72 15h ago
So, a human, who cannot - either permanently or temporarily - provide their own food and shelter should ... just go die?
-7
u/burndmymouth 14h ago
This happens every day. I'll give the example of being stranded on a desert island. You don't just get food and shelter. But you still have the right to pursue these things.Society can provide these things but they are not human rights.
-6
u/ThisPresentation5291 12h ago
They should stop taking drugs and go to the homeless shelter.
2
u/tw_72 10h ago
Since it is evident that you know nothing about homelessness, here is something for you to read.
https://www.councilforthehomeless.org/myths-facts-about-homelessness/
-2
u/ThisPresentation5291 9h ago
Homeless druggies are trash tho?
1
u/tw_72 7h ago
Your comment shows your ignorance and your lack of real-life experience. Good luck in your travels through life.
-2
u/ThisPresentation5291 6h ago
The opposite. Experience with worthless druggies leads to contempt for how trash they truly are.
3
3
u/lumaleelumabop 15h ago
Article 25
Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control.
-1
u/burndmymouth 14h ago
Oh yeah, what happens if you are stranded on a desert island?? You still have your human rights but everything you just mentioned is not miraculously just appearing for you.
1
16
u/Due_Regret8650 17h ago
I'd say from your comment that there are people who don't have the right to internet and it should be banned from them. It's fine that I have to put up with the nonsense of the idiot from my village, but also you, who I don't even know...
-2
u/burndmymouth 15h ago
You can turn the internet off, that is a definite right.
5
u/Due_Regret8650 15h ago
And yet I still wouldn't be able to get rid of stupid people who repeat the same stupid things, wherever they are. I'm doomed.
2
u/burndmymouth 15h ago
Educate yourself on what human rights are. Foundational Human Rights Principles
Human dignity.
Universality and interdependence of rights.
Equality and non-discrimination.
Meaningful participation.
Accountability and the right to an effective remedy
4
u/Due_Regret8650 15h ago
Human dignity is being able to eat, to begin with. The moment there is a single person who cannot eat and others who say they do not deserve it, human dignity does not exist. And if we play the law of the strongest, don't get in my way if I'm hungry.
1
u/burndmymouth 15h ago
Nope. Dignity has zero to do with eating. How about if there is a whole wipeout of the crops and there is no food, what right guarantees anyone eats? Again, tangible items are not human rights.
6
u/Due_Regret8650 15h ago
That dignity has nothing to do with eating? Sorry, I don't want to continue talking to someone who says such nonsense. Good afternoon.
16
u/mayocain 17h ago
You heard it here, folks, random Reddit user doesn't believe in natural rights, thousands of years of social theory suddenly invalid.
But, you're right, no one deserves anything. Remember that when you don't have kneecaps.
1
u/burndmymouth 16h ago
You guys are hysterical, so i "deserve" free food and shelter? News to me, I've had to work since about 15 to get everything I needed to survive. Where do I sign up for the free shit?? I could use it.
7
u/AquiliferX 15h ago
Well you could be on the receiving end of mutualism if you weren't a selfish prick railing against community led basic human rights like education, food, healthcare etc. You do realize that these investments in people pay dividends over time. But NOOO, you drank the capitalist Kool-Aid that "nothing comes free". You're right, it isn't free. It's built on the labor of those who work. But that labor distributed to those who need is what we mean by advocating for basic human material rights.
5
u/tw_72 15h ago
Good for you that you were able to work. What about those who can't?
- Single mother, husband died, 3 kids, she can't make enough money to cover daycare. Now what?
- Long-haul trucker, worked for years, back injury, can't work. Now what?
- Adult child with MS, cared for by mother, mother dies. Now what?
burndmymouth - you are not thinking broadly enough. You seem to assume that everyone is able to work and earn enough for the basics. Once you understand that is not reality for a lot of people - you might see things differently. Good luck to you in your journey.
0
u/burndmymouth 14h ago
I did not once say that we should not have welfare programs to help those less fortunate. My argument is that folks confuse human rights with these programs. To say food is a human right shows that you do not comprehend the concept. Take the example to the nth degree- if you say food is a basic human rights and then you find yourself stranded on a remote island how do you eat?
2
u/Wispy237 14h ago
By your logic, staying alive is not a human right, and if it is not, then that means that there are literally no human rights at all
1
u/burndmymouth 9h ago
Nice leap.
1
u/Wispy237 9h ago
Not really? If you have no right to food, you don’t really have a right to live do you? In case you didn’t realize, you kinda need food to live.
And if being alive isn’t a human right, what the fuck else would qualify?
2
u/mayocain 12h ago
*Fights against the people that want to supply food and shelter for all*
"WhERe Is ThE FrEE sHiT?"
You guys fucking fight against your own interest and then get surprised when the better world stays a pipedream.
4
u/mtw3003 17h ago
Luckily, nobody with the power to enforce their moral opinion shares yours
6
2
u/burndmymouth 16h ago
Really, I bet you do. How many homeless people live with you currently? How much extra of your income do you just send in to the government? I will bet that both of those answers are zero. Do you spend every waking hour helping those less fortunate than you? Doubt it.
5
u/Much-Jackfruit2599 16h ago
then why do we have taxes, the draft, shame people who step over people who have a heart attack?
0
u/burndmymouth 16h ago
WTF are you talking about. Taxes pay for infastructure, the draft is to supplement troop levels during a war. People who do not help someone dying are pieces of shit. But that doesn't mean everyone gets a free house and dinner, sorry but that's life.
3
u/Much-Jackfruit2599 16h ago
So you are okay with forced labour when it’s stuff you like.
0
u/burndmymouth 15h ago
Wow, that was a leap from my comment. Please explain how you interpreted anything I said to reach that conclusion.
2
u/Much-Jackfruit2599 15h ago
You defended draft and taxes for infrastructure necessary. Those are based on the labour of people, involuntary since you can’t opt out. You may want these things, others certainly disagree.
also, it’s a pretty wild leap to jump from “everybody deserves shelter and a meal” to giving houses away.
Also, why the heck do you care when people let other people die? You literally agreed that people aren’t owed shelter and food, two things whose lack greatly factor in people dying.
2
4
u/Budget_Classroom1028 14h ago
youre right its not like the entirety of human civilization or even the very concept of community is built upon helping others without expecting any personal gain
3
u/Jungle_gym11 16h ago
Nobody deserves basic freedoms or human rights? You have no humanity or empathy.
1
u/burndmymouth 16h ago
Wrong, everyone deserves basic freedoms and human rights. You are confusing welfare programs with human rights. Anything that someone has to pay for is not a right. Food costs money, property costs money. You can not force someone to work to provide someone else free anything.
1
u/Jungle_gym11 10h ago
So someone with disabilities that prevents them from working does not deserve support? Veterans do not deserve welfare programs? Orphans don't deserve support? Your view is limited and would lead to suffering for many of the most vulnerable.
1
u/burndmymouth 9h ago
I am not saying anyone doesn't deserve help. I am saying, by definition, food and shelter are not human rights.
1
u/Jungle_gym11 8h ago
You've slowly walked back your statement that nobody deserves anything.
There is no agreed definition of human rights. However, I would argue that it is a failure of the state if they are unable or unwilling to provide food and shelter to the most vulnerable. A measure of the success or priorities of a state are the standard of living of the most vulnerable.
161
u/MaxGlutePress 17h ago
Amazed at how cruel people have become