r/apple Jan 30 '24

Apple Vision Pro review: magic, until it’s not Apple Vision

https://www.theverge.com/24054862/apple-vision-pro-review-vr-ar-headset-features-price
2.7k Upvotes

View all comments

Show parent comments

347

u/Weekly-Dog228 Jan 30 '24

It seems the hype crowd / use cases did get a bit of hand.

The FOV + Mac screen sharing limitation has also taken away the dream of people having multiple displays.

You can have your Mac screen + Vision Pro app windows open all over the place.

But you cannot have multiple displays/windows for your Mac which was a use case I kept seeing mentioned in the comments. It’s a single window only.

105

u/anothermanscookies Jan 30 '24

Oh, that is disappointing. I thought that was the killer(if currently overpriced) use case. Surely will be addressed in an update.

145

u/timotheusthegreat Jan 30 '24

Purchased a Tesla in 2018 because it can drive itself without hands on the wheel. Still waiting on the update.

97

u/MVIVN Jan 30 '24

Like MKBHD always says in his reviews, never buy a product today based on the promise of potential future updates, because tech companies often fail to deliver — especially when it's ambitious stuff!

2

u/FluffyTV Jan 31 '24

PS5 says 8K on the box.

Companies will always fail upwards.

3

u/Beneficial-Mine7741 Jan 31 '24

Currently, PlayStation 5 is capable to support video games at an 8K resolution and has an HDMI 2.1 slot that enables the potential to play games in 8K resolution at 60 frame rates per second (FPS)

Only This game runs in 8k.

1

u/FluffyTV Jan 31 '24

Do you consider 1 game a success

2

u/Beneficial-Mine7741 Jan 31 '24

It isn't a Sony game. The answer must be no but it is still on the box.

1

u/MVIVN Jan 31 '24

The whole thing of people buying ridiculously expensive 8k tvs is such a joke to me. Where are these people expecting to find an abundance of 8k content to watch?

1

u/AdventurousDress576 Jan 31 '24

Well, it can run at 8K. But the market is so limited only 1 game has been developed, no one has an 8K TV.

30

u/anothermanscookies Jan 30 '24

I think we’ve learned in the last few years that Elon is not to be trusted. I’d put a bit more faith in Apple. Not an infinite amount, but a bit.

12

u/procrastinator67 Jan 30 '24

Yes, also one is a lot more tractable problem than the other

4

u/zdy132 Jan 31 '24

Then again, a first party calculator for iPad is almost trivial. Yet here we are.

3

u/CrassOf84 Jan 31 '24

Remember when they announced FaceTime as being open.

5

u/riseofr1ce Jan 31 '24

Don’t. I thought the M1 iPad Pro was going to be the future of computing and I finally caved and got a MacBook Pro. Wasted so much time with the iPad when the MacBook would have been better to get right away

0

u/professor-i-borg Jan 30 '24

The difference between the original iPhone with iPhone OS 1 and the iPhone 15/15 Pro with iOS 17 is solid evidence that Apple will eventually get it mostly right- the question is whether this new ecosystem will catch on and survive long enough for the iteration to happen.

1

u/caedin8 Jan 31 '24

It’s also a feature that hasn’t been promised

2

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '24

So the people who was sleep at the wheel while the telsa drove was fake? I thought some telsa could actually drive it’s self.

2

u/iPhoneXpensive Jan 31 '24

they come with some driver assistance, but offer two higher tiers of autonomous driving stuff for 6k and 12k

1

u/Redthemagnificent Jan 31 '24

Full self driving (FSD) is still in beta. So while yes, you can. How much do you trust beta self driving software that explicitly tells you to always be in full control? Not quite what was promised.

Also, the hardware used for FSD has changed on newer teslas vs the original model S, where he promised that they already had all the hardware they needed for future FSD.

0

u/Chewbongka Jan 31 '24

Tim Apple is not a con man like Elon Musk. Apple usually delivers.

107

u/zitterbewegung Jan 30 '24

Don’t rely on buying a product that will be fixed in a software update 

79

u/__theoneandonly Jan 30 '24

Especially if it’s a “fix” that the company has never promised.

3

u/Carvj94 Jan 31 '24

Apple already has an artifical limit on external displays in their low end SKUs. Good chance if they ever do fix it it'll only be for the high end models.

5

u/DamonHay Jan 31 '24

And especially if it’s an update that they could instead make more money from by selling it as a feature of the next generation.

1

u/Darmok-Jilad-Ocean Jan 31 '24

Or if it is one that Elon musk has promised

2

u/WeCanDoIt17 Jan 30 '24

Tell that to the people forking over 100k+ for the cybertruck

1

u/anothermanscookies Jan 30 '24

If $3500 wasn’t a lot of money for me, I’d be willing to try anyway. But it is, so I won’t have to worry about whether they add that feature for a while.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '24

[deleted]

1

u/zitterbewegung Jan 31 '24

What they did eventually release is that But they did put Logic Pro and Final Cut Pro on the iPad … and they had a keyboard with two usb c ports… 

5

u/PeterDTown Jan 30 '24

Future update requiring you to buy a new version.

5

u/crazysoup23 Jan 30 '24

Surely will be addressed in an update.

Right after iPad gets a first party calculator.

2

u/Sadtireddumb Jan 31 '24

Hey but we finally got a native weather app 12 years later though right

0

u/FollowingFeisty5321 Jan 30 '24

For two screens you’ll need the Pro or Max processor, that they can’t strap to your face.

1

u/Beh1ndBlueEyes Jan 30 '24

It's surely more of a data transfer rate problem than it’s a rendering issue. We’re talking Gbit/s for a single display.

1

u/FollowingFeisty5321 Jan 30 '24

It might not be, they describe it as being a "virtual display" so if that's treated like an external display it could be running into the M1/2/3 limitation of 2 screens with the other permanently-occupied by the physical screens for your eyes. Like trying to plug two monitors into your MBA; M1/2/3 only supports 2, Pro supports 3, Max supports 4, and internal displays permanently occupy one slot.

0

u/bobartig Jan 30 '24

It does seem like a software solution could handle it, although the window management problem might become more real. Vision Pro (it appears) allows you to have multiple floating window panes, but some limitation in how MacOS's windowserver (or some other technical part I don't know about), probably doesn't allow you to "abstract and float" a window anywhere because MacOS never anticipated needing to be able to do that. Yet.

-2

u/jdestinoble Jan 31 '24

Agreed. Many of these features we are disappointed are missing are probably already baked and plan for future updates. It doesn’t seem like a hardware limitation like the M Mac’s that can only have 1 plugged external display.

Fingers crossed tho, I know this is Apple I’m talking about so I’ll be patient.

I’ve got mine for pick up on the 3rd and will run it through my own tests, but I’m already quite sure it’s going to fit my daily lifestyle from the reviews so far.

Hoping for external controller support for gaming. Would love to play on my ps5 via remote play through the Vision Pro.

10

u/Logicalist Jan 30 '24

It’s a single window only.

New to the concept, but that makes sense right, since currently airplay is also just one screen? much more seems like a bandwidth issue.

5

u/artificialimpatience Jan 31 '24

I don’t know but the Quest 3 can do multiple windows on your Mac - up to five with apps like immersed.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '24

Yeah we're gonna need AirPlay3 with UWB or whatever.

0

u/Logicalist Jan 31 '24

There is that new wireless radio tech I can't remember the name of, that is on the newest iPhones. I'm sure we'll get more than one screen eventually, but I wouldn't hold my breath.

Is anyone streaming more than one screen wirelessly?

-4

u/FluffyTV Jan 31 '24

Come on. Just look at the competition. How long since we've been able to have Windows on however many screens you want. Even my Samsung phone has been able to act like a PC on whichever external screen for years. It's not a bandwidth issue. They're incompetent.

8

u/ButthealedInTheFeels Jan 30 '24

Wow I’m glad I cancelled my preorder I thought there was no way it would be limited to one single Mac display. That seems really stupid

1

u/Raudskeggr Jan 30 '24

Possibly hardware limitation? I know some of the macbook airs are limited to only one additional display too.

5

u/BMO888 Jan 30 '24

That’s fine but why limit the latest Pros?

Apple likes to slowly rollout features and I assume this is one of those features that will show up later. This Vision Pro feels so much like a beta test.

2

u/Raudskeggr Jan 30 '24

Yep. We can call this initial release "Series 0".

-1

u/Beh1ndBlueEyes Jan 30 '24

How do you suppose that the uncompressed data will reach the VP wirelessly? Which of the wireless technologies currently employed in any laptop would support transmitting many Gbit/s to support multiple high-res monitors?

4

u/runwithpugs Jan 30 '24

Why does it have to be uncompressed? We’ve had screen sharing on the Mac for ages with variable compression depending on network speed, and it looks great over local Wi-Fi. Same with AirPlay, and even CarPlay. I think they all use H.264 under the hood. I would assume this uses similar technology, if not the same.

1

u/Aromatic_Smoke_4052 Jan 30 '24

It pretty much is. There are no apps yet, it’s a test into a new market

2

u/needed_an_account Jan 30 '24

I saw someone post a link to a GitHub repo that would allow your Mac windows to freely float in the Vision Pro. That may help

1

u/TheDuckOnQuack Jan 30 '24

How much this matters to you probably depends a lot on what you’re using the display for. If you need to display multiple programs that only run on your Mac, seems like you’re out of luck unless the display is big enough to adequately show your programs in the same window.

If you’re used to a 3 monitor work setup like:

Center monitor: focus work

Left monitor: safari webpage or PDF that you reference to do your main work

Right monitor: a different webpage or PDF. Or maybe a music player or YouTube window that you periodically glance at

It seems like the Vision Pro would still be good option for that, assuming you can have multiple safari or preview windows open.

2

u/blacknoobie22 Jan 31 '24

I'm sorry, how is that better than just running 3 screens? Top of the line screens at that at half the price?

I use 3 screens almost all the time, yet I don't need a vision whatever the hell it's name is lol

0

u/TheDuckOnQuack Jan 31 '24

I’m not saying that makes it worth it, but responding to a concern somebody raised about a particular use case. But to answer your question, the two obvious advantages would be portability and it would take up less space if you have a smaller desk or want to use it on the couch.

0

u/Raudskeggr Jan 30 '24

So, I sometimes use my Xreal Air glasses to add more displays, virtually, to work with. On my PC I can also do this with the Quest 2. What, then, does the Vision Pro offer that I don't already have?

0

u/mgwair11 Jan 31 '24

Surely that’s a software update away though. Perhaps Mac osx update is required in conjunction with Vision Pro update and that is why it isn’t a feature that is launch ready? I hope. I have no intentions or personal interest in Vision Pro or mixed reality headsets for that matter, but I do want VR to grow and the only way to do that is for it to be mass adopted by the professional business world. Only way to actually get serious money into VR hardware and, by extension, VR software (which needs cash much much more).

1

u/MadOrange64 Jan 30 '24

Can the Mac screen thing be fixed with an update?

Or maybe it’ll be a marketing feature for the next gen Vision Pro…

1

u/the_old_coday182 Jan 30 '24

Does Apple even sell displays? That’s the only reason that would make sense.

1

u/Mumu_ancient Jan 30 '24

So if I'm understanding correctly that would kill the Idea of multi monitor NLE integration? Obviously not a major issue for most but a definite professional use case in future. Shouldn't that be fairly easy to fix? (Disclaimer - utterly no knowledge of how that would happen).

I dealt with configuring multiple monitor remote macs to PC based Avid suites over COVID and there always seemed to be an issue with security exceptions/ OS parity involving lots of tweaking but maybe that's not applicable here.

1

u/m1_weaboo Jan 31 '24

Tim Cook : M_ Pro/Max/Ultra needed for more than 1 virtual display

1

u/Mnawab Jan 31 '24

ya not only is this product in alpha technically but you also cant have multiple screens which is what i thought would be the most useful thing to have with this device. i see no point in getting this now until they change that.

1

u/peterosity Jan 31 '24

this one is reeaallly disappointing… people could’ve justified the spending by considering it a portable multi high end display solution for the mac. if people wanna use it for productivity, $3500 would give you a really high spec’d mbp…

also if anyone asks why productivity, because it’s what makes you money, and more people would find it justifiable when the expense could be written off as an investment in exchange for higher productivity

i hope they address these issues in the 2nd gen…

1

u/diegoarmando50 Jan 31 '24

Whaaat? Wasn't this like the main selling point?

1

u/East_Onion Feb 03 '24

wild Oculus could have desktop windows in 3D space 9 years ago and Vision can't today